The oldest s.f. magazine in my collection is about to turn one hundred. Actually, it may already be one hundred years old. This is volume 1, issue 9 of Amazing Stories, with an issue date of December 1926. Given how close we are at present to December 2026, it is almost certain that this magazine physically existed one hundred years ago, even if not yet on the newsstands.
The issue is in rough shape and I take it out of its protective slip case infrequently, as each time I do, a small cloud of pulp dust flakes off into the air. Like history in Ken Liu’s “The Man Who Ended History: A Documentary,” the magazine fades with each glance.
The contents of the issue begin with an impressive name, the first of a three-part serial by H. G. Wells, The First Men in the Moon. But looking down the rest of the names in that ancient December lineup, I am ashamed to admit I recognize none of the others. I feel marginally better about the names in the “In Our Next Issue” column, recognizing at once the name of Murray Leinster as the pen name of Will Jenkins, who had already been writing for a decade at this point, and who would go on to produce such classics as “Sidewise in Time11 Perhaps the first example of alternate history in science fiction.” (1934), “First Contact” (1945), and “A Logic Named Joe,” (1946) a story often credited with picturing what we now call the internet. Yet aside from Leinster and Wells, I recognize no other names there either.
I haven’t read the stories in the magazine. Such an attempt would almost certainly destroy what is left. But I have very carefully flipped through the pages once or twice. I noted the announcement that the next issue will begin a “discussion” section—a letter column. I noticed the ads from a time when my grandfather was but six years old.
Still, I sometimes take the issue off the shelf, as I did this morning, holding it carefully in its protective shield. I smell its smells, and wonder about the amazing journey this particular issue of Amazing Stories has taken. Who was the fellow who bundled it up at the printing press? Who was the man who dropped that bundle at a newsstand? Who was the child who bought the magazine, or who gained the magazine on some adult’s indulgence? Did they feel the same thrill that I do upon seeing the cover art, upon flipping open that cover to reveal the contents, the thrill at the familiar names, the wondrous titles?
How long did that youth hold on to the issue, and what became of it long after they had put away their childish things? Did it find its way to another generation? Did it sit on some back shelf in a musty second-hand bookshop for decades? Was it lost in the bottom of a trunk in a dusty attic for half a century? Did it travel? Find its way overseas to some G.I. near the frontline in Bastogne or Iwo Jima? Was it a prop in a 50s or 60s TV show or film, showing up for a flash in a background bookshelf? Did that child, who read part one of “The First Men on the Moon” live to see Neil Armstrong take his giant leap for mankind?
Old magazines, like old books, have a life and a story entirely separate from the one told between the covers. Sometimes, that story is the most interesting thing about it.
Perhaps the first example of alternate history in science fiction. ↩︎
Don’t adjust your screens. You have come to the right place. If it looks different it’s because I’ve recently done some remodeling. A new coat of paint, nice new flooring, and some new amenities that should make your time here a better overall experience.
I. Redesign
You may recall that I made an update to the blog theme a little over a year ago. I was enthusiastic about it at first, but over time, my enthusiasm waned. I felt like I lost something in that redesign. Things have been quiet here and that gave me time to consider what I was looking for. I considered the simple and elegant layouts I’ve seen in places over the years. One example kept returning to me: the page layout of Will Durant’s Our Oriental Heritage. I decided to use that as my starting point, and you are seeing the result here.
I’ve written about how I like making marginal notes while reading. I’ve applied that idea to the new blog theme so that footnotes and similar commentary appear in the margins11 Like this. if you are viewing the page on a wide screen. On narrower screens and mobile devices, they appear as normal footnotes at the end of the page.
The home page now shows the full text of the five most recent posts I’ve made. Scroll down beyond those five, and you’ll see a listing of older posts by date. I’ve simplified and consolidated some of the menus, and updated some of the static pages. If you are new to the blog, there is a Start Here page that provides some suggestions from a variety of subjects that I’ve written about over the years.
There are other, more subtle design changes: dark mode that follows your device’s settings, threaded comments, and more. I hope that they combine to make for a more pleasant reading experience.
II. An Improved Reading List
And since reading is a big part of what I write about, I have finally gotten around to completely revamping my reading list to make it more useful to anyone who wants to see it. Previously, my list was kept as a plain-text (markdown format) file hosted by Obsidian Publish. With my archive system, ark, which has evolved into a kind of LifeOS, I have now automated the list from the source data in my archive. Rather than publish it to Obsidian Publish, the list is published here, on the blog in a way that allows for easy searching, filtering, and drilling down into more details.
By default, the list displays the reading #, Title, Author(s), Date finished, and Subject. Those columns are now sortable and filterable.
It is now easy to see how many times I’ve read a book before. On a given reading line, if I’ve read a book more than once, you’ll see the reading # below the title. For instance, see The Forever War and Starship Troopers in the image above.
The list displays one hundred books at a time by default, which can be paged through, or you can click the “Full list” link at the top of the table to see all of the books in a single page. I’ve also provided download links to download the current reading list in markdown and PDF format.
New to this list is the ability to click on a book to see more details.
The book displays basic information: its author(s), category, and ratings22 I’ve complained in the past about 5-star rating systems. I don’t use such a system in my ratings. Instead, you’ll see what I call “bands.” A book gets a score that falls into a band. In the example of Starship Troopers, it falls into the highest band, a “Keeper.” See the About the List page for more information on my ratings. (for some books). You’ll also see the book’s reading history, including times that I abandoned the book. Abandoned readings33 These abandoned readings come automatically from data in my archive. For instance, if a diary entry indicates that I gave up on a book, the archive interprets this as an abandonment. It also infers abandonments from Audible and Kindle data. And of course, I can mark a book as abandoned myself. don’t show on the list by default because only books that I finish reading get a reading number. But the list filter will display them if you want to see them. If there is a cover for the book in my archive, the cover is displayed. Because my entire book collection is in my archive, I have covers, title pages, copyright pages, and inscriptions for many of them and so you are seeing my actual copies of the physical books in these cases.
Another new feature that ark handles for me is “Posts that mention this book.” When I first ingested my blog into ark one of the tasks I gave it was to identify books mentioned in posts and link them to the source book in the archive. This happens automatically now as part of the archive’s nightly work and so I can easily link to posts that mention a particular title.
Want to know what I am currently reading? Click on the “Reading Now” page. Want to see some cool reading stats? There’s a page for that, too.
The best part of this, for me, is not just having it out there in one place, but having the entire process automated. If I finished reading a book today, I tell ark and tomorrow, that book will appear on the list with no further action on my part.
So there you have it. A big blog refresh that I’ve been wanting to do for some time now. Try it out. Give it a spin. Let me know if something isn’t working. Let me know if there are features you’d like to see that aren’t here yet. I’d love to get your feedback.
I’ve complained in the past about 5-star rating systems. I don’t use such a system in my ratings. Instead, you’ll see what I call “bands.” A book gets a score that falls into a band. In the example of Starship Troopers, it falls into the highest band, a “Keeper.” See the About the List page for more information on my ratings. ↩︎
These abandoned readings come automatically from data in my archive. For instance, if a diary entry indicates that I gave up on a book, the archive interprets this as an abandonment. It also infers abandonments from Audible and Kindle data. And of course, I can mark a book as abandoned myself. ↩︎
It has taken me thirty years, but I finally think I know what I like, and don’t like in science fiction stories; what, for me, creates a sense of wonder.
Thirty years ago, I was deep into my science fiction education. I finished the month of October 1996 by reading Ray Bradbury’s Something Wicked This Way Comes and Kim Stanley Robinson’s Red Mars. I then spent the entire month of November immersed in the genre: Chorale and Herovit’s World by Barry N. Malzberg, Way Station by Clifford D. Simak, The Space Merchants by Frederik Pohl and Cyril Kornbluth, Fahrenheit 451 and The Martian Chronicles by Bradbury, Sundiver by David Brin, City of Truth by James Morrow. In fact, between 1996-2006, almost one in three books I read were science fiction. Compare that to the last ten years (2016-2026) where only one in 22 books that I read were science fiction. To illustrate this plainly, here is the last three decades of my science fiction reading as a fraction of my overall reading11 Those who have been following my writing about my personal archive system, ark, can thank that system for this chart. All of the data lives in ark and all I had to do was ask it to produce the chart for me..
What happened?
During those first ten years, the butterfly effect of reading began flapping its wings. My interests expanded and my reading expanded with it. I didn’t want to be a one-genre reader, and I have had some success in that regard.
More significantly, rather than accepting the opinions of history, I formed my own opinions and my own tastes about what I read. I didn’t exactly tire of science fiction, but I found much of what I read in the genre tiring22 Ironically, it wasn’t until right after this period, in 2007, that I began selling the science fiction I was writing. So perhaps there was a third force at work: I didn’t want to corrupt what I was writing with what I was reading.. When I would pick up an s.f. book to read, I’d often get in just a few pages, become restless, and move on to something else.
In 2026, the chart shows a modest decrease in that ratio. Ten months into the year, the ratio of books read to science fiction books read is 6-to-1. Many of these have been nostalgic re-reads. I started the year reading (and re-reading) Asimov. I recently finished reading Kim Stanley Robinson’s Aurora, and as I write this, I am reading The Year’s Best Science Fiction, First Annual Collection and Ursula K. Le Guin’s collection of critical essays The Language of the Night.
My journey across the science fiction landscape mirrors the way I tackle many areas I become interested in: a balance between depth and breadth. There are several areas in which I feel qualified to speak with some authority, notably the Golden Age, my education of which came from my Vacation in the Golden Age of Science Fiction series. I feel like I have some authority in Asimov’s science fiction, and I’ve sampled long and short form science fiction across most of its existence.
But there are gaps. I’ve read little new s.f. in the last 10 years or so. And “gaps” would be a generous term for what I’ve missed in short fiction of the 1950s and 1980s and 1990s. “Canyons” would be more fitting. That is why I decided to pick up Gardner Dozois’ first annual collection of The Year’s Best Science Fiction. After reading a novel as great as Robinson’s Aurora, I was inspired to go back and fill some of those gaps. I’m glad I did for it was within the first seven stories of The Year’s Best that I had an epiphany thirty years in the making.
When I started reading science fiction, it was by accident. Someone gave me Isaac Asimov’s The Caves of Steel in the early 1980s. I was curious, but never made it past the first or maybe second chapter. Other genre books were more successful, like David Oromondroyd’s David and the Phoenix and Madeline L’Engle’s A Wrinkle in Time. It wasn’t until 7th grade, however, when my friend Noah turned me on to books by Piers Anthony, that I really found a love for the genre33 I’ve written about this before, but I actually read a Piers Anthony book before that, in sixth grade. It was Race against Time. I just didn’t pay attention to authors back then and didn’t realize that Anthony was the author until much later.. Back then, I read for the fun of it, for the novelty of it, for the thrill. I didn’t think much about it.
In college I became more systematic, expanding beyond the handful of authors whose new books I’d read, to authors across the spectrum of science fiction. It was then that I re-encountered Asimov and read “Nightfall” for the first time. I discovered Harlan Ellison and Barry N. Malzberg. And I discovered short science fiction on the newsstand in the glossy pages of Science Fiction Age. From there, it was a steady progression to where I was thirty years ago. And it was around that time that I began to notice that certain science fiction stories blew me away, while many of them were just okay, or even—and I’m sorry to say this—grating on me. It never occurred to me to ask why. I assumed I was growing out of the genre.
But in those first seven stories of Dozois’s first annual best-of anthology, I found the answer, and looking back, I’d had hints of it along the way. Three of the seven stories were great. Two especially. The rest paled in comparison. The three great stories were “Beyond the Dead Reef” by James Tiptree, Jr.44 Alice Sheldon, as we now know., “Man-Mountain Gentian” by Harold Waldrop, and “Manifest Destiny” by Joe Haldeman. In thinking about what made those stories stand out among the others, my personal epiphany, was this:
For me, science fiction cannot know that it is science fiction. The story has to be told as if it is just any other story, unfolding to a set of characters who live in the world, unaware that they are characters, unobserved by outsiders.
What does that mean? For one thing, a good science fiction story, for me, does not emphasize a world or setting as something unusual, unless it would be unusual to the characters in it. It hasn’t been waving its literary hands at the reader, jumping up and down and shouting, “check out how cool and bizarre this is!” which is exactly what Bruce Sterling’s “Cicada Queen” seemed to do. Rather, the reader sees the world through the eyes of the character and the frame of the story, and the characters are not aware that they are characters in a story.
One concrete example of the opposite of this—the writer intruding into the story—is when nouns in science fiction become proper nouns. In Greg Bear’s “Hardfought” there is a line that reads, “Until her first battle she would be educated in the Know and the Tell.” I cannot recall an instance where I turned nouns into proper nouns in my head in the ordinary course of life. I saw this technique a lot in my Vacation in the Golden Age and it never failed to pull me—no, jerk me bodily—out of the story. That type of writing pre-imagines an audience reading, not a reader experiencing. The intent, I suspect, was to show how different the characters/setting is from us. But the characters and the setting don’t know they are different from us. They don’t know us at all. And so a better approach, in my mind, is a simple, “Until her first battle she would be educated in science and literature” or whatever the Show and the Tell really are.
A good science fiction story doesn’t think of itself as science fiction. This seems to hold for the three stories I really enjoyed. There were science fictional elements to all three but the characters and settings were not aware that they were science fiction. There were no info-dumps and technobabble. There was no one cursing “Galaxy!” These stories were subtle, they trust the reader to learn what is happening and interpret it, and that is a big part of what makes any fiction work well.
Since I had just finished reading and enjoying Robinson’s Aurora, I tested my newfound insight against it. In the case of that novel, it is the framing of the story that works in its favor. Portions of the narrative are framed as an attempt of the ship’s AI to generate a narrative of the ship at the request of one of the people on board. This ship’s AI is trying to understand how to do this. It needs to convey technical information, but it also assumes it is generating a narrative not for some external reader, but for someone within the story, who already has much of the background. Thus, much is assumed and the reader has to take hints and clues and piece things together on their own, the way they would in real life.
I’m reminded of my experience reading James Clavell’s Shōgun. In that novel, Clavell doesn’t explain Japanese culture of the early 17th century to us. Rather, we pick it up through the eyes of Blackthorn as he learns it himself, just as we learn a few words of Japanese, not from direct translations, but as Blackthorn picks them out through experience. It is work, sometimes hard work, and it makes all the difference between mediocrity and greatness.
Looking back over the science fiction I have read, I can see that my idea of what makes good science fiction is reflected in those books and stories that stood out to me among the rest. This is also true for the stories I liked best during my Vacation in the Golden Age, stories like “Rust” by Joseph E. Kelleam, “Greater Than Gods” by C.L. Moore, Final Blackout by L. Ron Hubbard, “Requiem” and Methuselah’s Children by Robert A. Heinlein, “Nightfall” by Isaac Asimov and “Microcosmic God” by Theodore Sturgeon, among several others.
Heinlein was particularly good at this. Many of his best stories immersed the reader without explaining the details of what was going on. The reader is an invisible part of the culture in the stories, and any member of that culture has a sense of the culture that doesn’t require explanation. I think this is what made some of his novels, like Double Star and Friday stand out. Clarke only occasionally managed this, as with his story “The Star.” The opening line of Joe Haldeman’s The Forever War just about spells it out: “Tonight we’re going to show you eight silent ways to kill a man.” The reader is a recruit along with the rest of the characters, not an interloper peeking in from the outside.
There are times when this wall between the reader and the story can work, but it is often in satiric or recursive stories. Barry N. Malzberg makes good, almost exaggerated, use of the technique in Beyond Apollo and Galaxies. In both cases, the framing of the story plays an important role.
I’m not entirely sure that this is what I have strived for in my own writing, but I see it reflected there in ways I never realized before, and framing has been a useful tool in that regard. My first Analog story, “Take One for the Road” tells the story of the mysterious events of a manned mission to Mercury, framed through the next-door neighbor of the only remaining astronaut from that mission. My story “Big Al Shepard Plays Baseball on the Moon” is framed through a eulogy. “Gemma Barrows Comes to Cooperstown” is framed as a nonfiction piece for a sports magazine.
This new perspective becomes a useful filter. It makes it easier for me to identify what does and doesn’t work for me and allows me a better sieve for sifting through the stockpile of science fiction and sorting out the gems from the dross. It is an equally good filter for my own writing, a much clearer signal to me, of what works, and what I should avoid.
Those who have been following my writing about my personal archive system, ark, can thank that system for this chart. All of the data lives in ark and all I had to do was ask it to produce the chart for me. ↩︎
Ironically, it wasn’t until right after this period, in 2007, that I began selling the science fiction I was writing. So perhaps there was a third force at work: I didn’t want to corrupt what I was writing with what I was reading. ↩︎
I’ve written about this before, but I actually read a Piers Anthony book before that, in sixth grade. It was Race against Time. I just didn’t pay attention to authors back then and didn’t realize that Anthony was the author until much later. ↩︎
I recently took John Quincy Adams to Alaska with me. He’d spent a good chunk of the first part of his life traveling through Europe and was more traveled than most people of his era. But he’d never been to Alaska and I felt bad about that. And as I happened to be heading that way, I thought I’d take him with me. It wasn’t much of an inconvenience. I tucked him inside my backpack. He didn’t seem to mind.
At some point this year, I decided that I should spend some of my reading time going through primary sources. I’d re-read some of Stephen Jay Gould’s essay collections and was impressed by how frequently he went to primary sources, even in preparing for his essays. I realized that as widely as I have read in science, history, and biography, I rarely tackled primary sources. The Library of America two volume set of John Quincy Adams Diaries sit near my desk and I decided that those would be the first primary source to tackle.
My first significant encounter with the sixth President of the United States was a quarter of a century ago, when I read John Adams by David McCullough. Prior to that, I knew that he was the sixth President and that he was the son of John Adams, the second President of the United States, but not much more. McCullough’s book began a lifelong fascination with the Adams family.11 In addition to McCullough’s book, I’ve read *Friends Divided: John Adams and Thomas Jefferson* by Gordon S. Wood, *John Adams Under Fire* by Dan Abrams and David Fisher, *John Quincy Adams* by Fred Kaplan, *John Quincy Adams: Militant Spirit* by James Traub, *John Quincy Adams* by Randall B. Woods, and *A Perfect Coincidence* by Jim Rasenberger.
It’s fair to say that I thought I knew John Quincy Adams.
Reading his diaries, however, was an experience unlike any I’d had before. JQA is famous for the diaries he kept, more than 14,000 pages from about 1779–1848, a good span of his life. The Library of America editions don’t contain all 14,000 pages in order to avoid unnecessary repetition. But they provided enough of his diary writing to make me feel as if I knew JQA better than most people I’ve read about.
In reading history and biography, both the writer and the reader have some sense of what is to come and can cast the narrative with those future events in mind. In memoir and autobiography, the subject is writing about the past with full knowledge of how things turned out and that knowledge pollutes the timeline. JQA wrote his diaries contemporaneously with the times he lived in, with each entry, he had no idea of what the future would hold, even as we, the reader, does. It provided a tension that drew me into the book the way a good story draws the reader in by its plot.
The first entries in the diary were written when JQA was still a boy. The final entry in the second volume came three days before he died at age 80. Reading the volumes from start to finish gives such a complete picture of one man’s life that it is impossible not to know him. Through approximately 1,300 pages, I watched him grow, learn, form opinion, some rash, some mature for his young age. I watched those opinions morph and change as he grew in experience. Many of the attitudes and opinions he wrote about in the second half of his life were clearly formed from earlier experiences.
Adams was critical of himself, frequently berating himself for slacking off, or not doing as well at a task as he believed he was capable of. This critical eye followed him throughout his entire life. The introspection probably helped him achieve all that he managed to achieve in his lifetime.
He wrote in great detail about his negotiations with foreign ministers when he was himself a minister and his diary entries analyzing the negotiations, the situations, the people, are a masterclass in diplomacy.
As I read, I scribbled ferociously in the margins, capturing thoughts, notes, behaviors, observations, more than 130 of these in total. And that doesn’t count the ones that I lost.
Upon leaving Alaska, I continued to read the first volume of JQAs diaries on an Alaska Airlines flight from Fairbanks to Seattle. It was a late flight22 In his lifetime, JQA traveled across the Atlantic by ship many times, each time taking at minimum five to six weeks. He traveled from Boston to New York or Philadelphia or Washington, D.C. by coach, which would take up to two weeks. Later in his life, however, he traveled by steamship, which cut down travel time significantly, and later still, by train. The increase in the speed of travel in his lifetime was much more noticeable than in my own., dark out as we made our final approach into SeaTac airport. I was tired from the vacation. We deplaned, picked up our luggage, and got an Uber to our hotel. As we finally settled into bed for the evening I went to pull out my copy of JQA’s diaries only to find it missing. It took only a few moments to realize that I’d left the book in the seat back on the plane. I was abashed! The book itself was easily replaced. The marginal notes that I’d not yet captured in my archive were lost for good!33 I did submit a lost item report to Alaska Airlines, but after a month, the report was closed. The book was never located. My guess is that it was tossed out. Meanwhile, I acquired another volume, without, of course, my original marginal notes.
I got lucky with my first foray into primary sources. Looking back on it, I can say without hesitation that JQAs diaries are the finest American literature that I have come across so far.
I am now well into the second volume of Gibbon’s Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire. While this is not exactly a primary source, it is turning out to be far more engaging than I initially imagined it would be.
In addition to McCullough’s book, I’ve read *Friends Divided: John Adams and Thomas Jefferson* by Gordon S. Wood, *John Adams Under Fire* by Dan Abrams and David Fisher, *John Quincy Adams* by Fred Kaplan, *John Quincy Adams: Militant Spirit* by James Traub, *John Quincy Adams* by Randall B. Woods, and *A Perfect Coincidence* by Jim Rasenberger. ↩︎
In his lifetime, JQA traveled across the Atlantic by ship many times, each time taking at minimum five to six weeks. He traveled from Boston to New York or Philadelphia or Washington, D.C. by coach, which would take up to two weeks. Later in his life, however, he traveled by steamship, which cut down travel time significantly, and later still, by train. The increase in the speed of travel in his lifetime was much more noticeable than in my own. ↩︎
I did submit a lost item report to Alaska Airlines, but after a month, the report was closed. The book was never located. My guess is that it was tossed out. Meanwhile, I acquired another volume, without, of course, my original marginal notes. ↩︎
Just a quick note to say that I am alive and well, and desperately trying to find a way back to writing here on the blog. Several readers have reached out to see if everything is okay, given that I’ve gone dark since July. I’m touched by the concern. But really, everything is okay. Life is just busy at the moment, consuming enough mental energy to make it difficult to write.
Since we last met…
I was writing about ark, the personal archive I’ve been working on. I started building ark on March 31. One reason I haven’t written more about it is that, since my last post in the series, ark has grown and morphed and changed into something more like a personal archive/LifeOS. I hesitate to write about it when it is changing and growing so much each day. And to be honest, given how much time I spend working on it, I don’t feel like thinking about it when I am off the clock. Here’s a look at the time I’ve spent working on ark this year.
We took the family to Alaska. That explains the gap in the work on ark in August. We flew to Vancouver, spent a few days there, and then boarded a cruise ship that took us on a seven day journey up to Ketchikan, Juneau, Skagway, and finally, Whittier. From there, we did a land tour, by bus and train up to Fairbanks, spending a few nights at lodges in Denali National Park. From Fairbanks, we flew to Seattle and spent three days there doing touristy things, and visiting family.
I’ve been busy with work, managing one really big (and seemingly endless) project, and just completing the roll-out of a small, high-value project.
I’ve been reading a lot, including going to some primary sources. I recently read the Library of America’s 2-volume John Quincy Adams Diaries, which turned out to be one of the best things I’ve read in American literature. I’m into the second volume of Gibbon’s The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire. And since, today, the new Stephen King novel Other Worlds Than These came out, and since I’ve never read either The Talisman or Black House, I’ve been making my way through those so that the new book will make more sense.
The “Little Man” (who is no longer little) is a senior in high school and going through all of the machinations involved in applying to colleges. Remember when he was born? It seems like yesterday.
I hope that helps explain my absence. I frequently tell myself I should be writing more. I have a list of topics to write about. I just need to reorient myself to this new busy and figure out when I can fit it in. I’m sure I’ll get it figured out.
To those who have reached out, I truly appreciate your concern, and it is another motivator to get me writing here again. You are the best!